I've gone to two concerts recently, Joan Baez and a symphonic concert. As usual, I went to dinner before each concert, which usually involves a couple glasses of wine. When I got to my symphonic seat, the music began and after a few minutes I.., I..., I fell asleep.
This wasn't the first time. I mean, I try to stay awake, but the lights go down, it's warm, the music is soothing.... What can I do? (yeah, yeah, I should probably abstain before a concert.) I'm always alert for the second half, but so often I'm in and out at the top.
When I took my Joan Baez seat, the lights went down, the sold out house was indeed warm, the music was relaxing... and I stayed awake! I didn't try to stay awake, I just did.
My wife observed that with Joan Baez each song was 3 or 4 minutes long, there was light excercise (clapping), and a brief story to introduce each song. Even though it was a pretty low energy concert, it kept my attention from the beginning.
Which got me to thinking that a concert's format may have a lot to do with keeping a listener's attention. Or not.
Comments
John and Steve, John raises
Sun, 11/12/2006 - 10:06pm — Jonathan MillerJohn and Steve, John raises the very problem to which my programming attempts to be a solution. While a 15-minute movement may have many "moods" inside it, I tend to prefer to create the moods by having short pieces -- 2 to 4 minutes, sometimes 5 or 6 -- which are each clearly defined by mood, style, texture, and poetry. I reject the notion that audiences should just "get it" and not be bored. Our listeners listen to pop and folk and jazz -- just like John! -- and classical music does not exist in a vacuum. People have been conditioned by radio and even CDs to listen to back-to-back songs that create rapidly varying moods. Why shouldn't we do what captures people's imagination? Nobody is bored at a Chicago a cappella concert! Jonathan Miller
Steve, Jonathan, thanks for
Wed, 11/15/2006 - 2:06pm — John RyanSteve, Jonathan, thanks for your comments. a big ditto on concert dress. As I've thought about this since the original post, I've warmed up to the idea of more short pieces, especially at the begining of a concert. I'm looking forward to continuing this conversation in my Friday blog. Best. John
John, one of my favorite
Fri, 11/10/2006 - 11:08pm — Steve BurkholderJohn, one of my favorite ever concerts was when I bought nosebleed seats at Heinz Hall in Pittsburgh for a concert that consisted entirely of Shostakovich's 11th. A 65 minute long piece! At first I was worried I would doze, but I swear that by wearing jeans and a t-shirt to the show and having almost no one in the seats near me, I felt much more comfortable to fuss and fidget here and there, and generally feel at home. I was riveted for the whole show! I've always thought that the whole ritual of sitting straight and still for a couple of hours induces sleep, no matter how great the concert. Of course, so does a couple of glasses of wine!
Post new comment